While perusing shops for a new duvet cover is arguably more fun, a comforter is what keeps you warm at night. Here are options that will keep you toasty and last through multiple winters. (Plus, they make a great gift for a recent grad or newly married couple!)

Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter

Take it from a recent rave review that reads, “No loose feathers, no flatness – just warm, weightless, fluffy perfection.” It’s not the cheapest on the market, but it’s important to look for quality when shopping for a new comforter, which this choice provides in spades. It’s also made from ethically sourced materials!

Brooklinen Down Comforter

Made with a 100 percent cotton sateen shell for extra softness and a lightweight filling perfect for those who get hot at night, Brooklinen’s comforter is a great all-season option. While the brand is better known for its sheets, this bedding addition is just as luxurious.

White Bay Down Comforter

For those who like options, this comforter comes in five different colors and four different warmth levels—from super light to extra. The sateen shell is 300-thread count, ethically sourced, and hypoallergenic.

Parachute Down Duvet Insert

Parachute makes its duvet inserts with “750 fill power European white down, prized for its superior fluffiness and warmth,” so you can expect the ultimate night’s sleep by going with this option. Choose between lightweight or all season at checkout.

Bavarian 850 Down Comforter

Sometimes you know exactly what you want, and this heavyweight comforter good enough to withstand an arctic winter. Feathered Friends’ Bavarian Comforter literally has an ‘arctic’ option for those who get extra chilly during the night.

Riley White Goose Down Comforter

Wirecutter, GQ, and Apartment Therapy have all raved about this ultra-thick duvet that comes in two options: all season or extra warm. In fact, you may not need a duvet cover at all with how soft and luxurious this comforter looks and feels on its own.